0; 12; 24; 36 100; 50; 25; 12 25 3 The review starts with a summary of the article's contents the perspective of which is geared towards what will follow in the review text. The review starts with a generic summary of the article's contents The review starts with a minimal token summary of the article's contents The review appears partially dubious The review appears fully sound and trustworthy The review appears almost fully sound and trustworthy The review appears by-and-large sound and trustworthy The review appears partially dubious The review covers all important issues The review leaves one important issue undiscussed The review leaves several important issues undiscussed For any strength or issue mentioned, the review provides clear indication how important it is For most strengths or issues mentioned, the review provides clear indication how important it is For at least some strengths or issues mentioned, the review provides clear indication how important it is Otherwise The review explicitly and clearly weighs strengths against weaknesses to arrive at its recommendation The review vaguely weighs strengths against weaknesses to arrive at its recommendation No weighing is apparent, the recommendation might surprise someone who has read the review text